Project

General

Profile

Actions

Emulator Issues #1897

closed

Bad Sound in Punch Out!

Added by richards.rodrigo over 14 years ago.

Status:
Fixed
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
% Done:

0%

Operating system:
N/A
Issue type:
Bug
Milestone:
Regression:
No
Relates to usability:
No
Relates to performance:
No
Easy:
No
Relates to maintainability:
No
Regression start:
Fixed in:

Description

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1.Open Dolphin
2.Start Punch Out! and play it.

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?
While playing I hear a sound that is really bad and sounds like a zombie or
as if in slow motion

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
I`m using Dolphin x86 4758 and Windows XP SP3 x86.

Please provide any additional information below.
This also happens in the cutsenes of Super Smash Bros Brawl maybe other
games have this issues.


Related issues 2 (0 open2 closed)

Has duplicate Emulator - Emulator Issues #3077: Punch Out in R6109 as far back as i can rememberDuplicate

Actions
Has duplicate Emulator - Emulator Issues #3900: Punch out sound problemDuplicate

Actions
Actions #2

Updated by ayuanx over 14 years ago

Just try Dsound, if not working, try hold down key on keyboard

Actions #3

Updated by richards.rodrigo over 14 years ago

i have tried with Dsound and Disable other sound (tab is the shortcut) and nothing i
still have the bad sound.

Actions #4

Updated by ayuanx over 14 years ago

Then you have to wait for LLE maybe

Actions #6

Updated by Anonymous over 13 years ago

Please respond if this issue is still valid, or it will be closed.

Actions #7

Updated by Anonymous over 13 years ago

Still valid. At least with me.
Using latest rev 6604 and a older one 5643 (with FIFO patch).
All plugins tested(dx9/11/opengl);
tested with differents settings
sound really bad (reffer to issue 3077 too). LLE plugin works a little better.
PC: E5200@3.85/4gb ram/HD 4770 512mb.

Actions #8

Updated by skidau over 13 years ago

Issue 3900 has been merged into this issue.

Actions #9

Updated by skidau over 13 years ago

Issue 3077 has been merged into this issue.

Actions #10

Updated by ginoherrera2010 over 13 years ago

This issue have over a year and still no satisfactory answer or when it will start

I think there should be a review of these old issues and give the importance they deserve.

Actions #11

Updated by wespipes69 over 13 years ago

It's pretty darn good in LLE. Try it on new rev.

All the sounds bugs will be invalid when LLE takes over and that will be soon. Most of my games are now full speed with it. We just need one more big performance boost and we're there!!

Actions #12

Updated by Juliannb4 about 13 years ago

Maybe the problem is the ISO's region, I have Punch Out on PAL Multi5, like you, according the videos, and some times sounds good, but you have the problem more serious that me. Try out with another region, I'm gonna try too. If it works, I'll let you know.
See ya.
(Quizás el problema sea de la región del ISO, yo tenngo el Punch Out en PAL Multi5, como vos, según los videos, y a veces suena bien, pero vos tenés un problema más serio que el mío. Probá con otra región, voy a probarlo también. Si funciona, te lo haré saber.
Saludos.)

Actions #13

Updated by florian98.rg about 13 years ago

Use DSP LLE

Actions #14

Updated by ebenezergrymm about 13 years ago

DSP LLE doesnt fix the issue. No audio selection does.

Since this topic was started in '09 though the issue has changed a bit. Currently LLE gets the best sound with 60 fps framerate throughout the whole game EXCEPT for two parts.

Part 1- MASSIVE drop in framerate on the career opponent select screen. You go from 60 in the rest of the game to ~20 FPS. This occurs when you enter the screen, then disappears until you cycle through opponents. What makes this seem to be a sound issue is that there's a big "WHOOSH"ing noise that plays when you first enter the screen, and a similar "WHOOSH" as you cycle through opponents. So it would seem that the massive framerate drop is due to Dolphin not being able to handle that "WHOOSH" noise correctly.

Part 2- This might not actually be a problem at all, or it may be similar to the first one. It's during Mr Sandmans entrance. It's close to the same type of frame drop as the opponent select screen. Theres sounds here that arent heard anywhere else in the game, his big "BOOM"ing footsteps. It may be that Dolphin isnt handling them properly. Or it may just be that since his entrance shows a large part of the arena it's just an intensive spot. Or a combination of both.

But yeah, contrary to the OP from two years ago those are the only remaining issues with sound in PunchOut!! Sound and speed overall have improved significantly except for the two spots I've mentioned.

Maybe they're some type of surround sound type of sounds not being output properly, don't know. They would both fit that description.

Actions #15

Updated by Anonymous about 13 years ago

Are there still issues with punch out if you disable the patch which is in the ini file for this game? I forget exactly what that patch does :)

Actions #16

Updated by wespipes69 about 13 years ago

I have no sound issues - LLE plus Sandy.

Thanks for the db scrub Godisgovernment!

Actions #17

Updated by Anonymous about 13 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Fixed

wespipes96: cool

ebenezer: unfortunately dsp lle can't be held accountable for bad noises produced when dolphin isn't running full speed :/ we need a time-stretcher or make it faster.

Actions #18

Updated by Tacobot over 12 years ago

I don't think this issue is resolved. Or at least it got broken again with a new revision. If I use LLE I get horrible stuttering during fights, and if I use HLE I get weird slow motion zombie sounds. Tried every permutation of sound settings.

Actions #19

Updated by wespipes69 over 12 years ago

You need a better cpu obviously.

Actions #20

Updated by deckerj over 12 years ago

I'm running on a core i7 2600k clocked at 4.2Ghz and have the same problem.

Actions #21

Updated by samljer over 12 years ago

its not my CPU ass. i have a Phenom FX quad at 3.8ghz

Actions #22

Updated by parlane over 12 years ago

Yea, that's so last year. Get some sandy bridges.

Actions #23

Updated by Tacobot over 12 years ago

I've got a Phenom II 965, running rev 3.0-415. I don't think it's my cpu because people with more powerful ones have the same problem. The game isn't slowing down, the sound just stutters.

Actions #24

Updated by samljer over 12 years ago

Post if from 2009 parlane, you dummy.

Actions #25

Updated by wespipes69 over 12 years ago

Chill out saml, what crawled up your sensitive butt? Not wise to attack devs.

I have a i5 2500k (clock at 4.3) and just tried playing it again. Speed is flawless with LLE active. It IS your cpus, not Dolphin.

Actions #26

Updated by samljer over 12 years ago

not wise to attack devs? first off i wasnt. and even if i was there if fuk all they can do about it. ban me? go ahead i got 3 google accounts linked to different regions, fuck them too imo.

Actions #27

Updated by Anonymous over 12 years ago

Watch out. We got a badass here.

Actions #28

Updated by Tacobot over 12 years ago

Is it my cpu? Or is it because dolphin sucks at LLE?

Just kidding. I accept defeat. Thanks guys.

Actions #29

Updated by parlane over 12 years ago

The fact that he still has a Yahoo account says a lot.

Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF